All Journals > Journal of Consumer Research > October 2008 > Flying under the Self‐Control Radar

Search for Related Articles

Press Release

The Anti-Consumption Movement: Researchers Examine Resistance to Global Brands

The Sweet Taste of Uncertainty: Winners Enjoy Waiting to Discover What They’ve Won

The Dark Side of Gifts: Feeling Indebted May Drive People to the Marketplace

The Complicated Consumer: Positive Ads Aren’t Always the Most Effective

The Freebie Dilemma: Consumers Are Skeptical About “Free” Products

How Consumers Continue Enjoying their Favorite Experiences

Extended Service Contracts: When and Why Do People Buy Them?

In the News

Featured in Scientific American
"Mixing memory with reality can bring pleasure to the routine" June 17, 2009
Variety Amnesia: Recalling Past Variety Can Accelerate Recovery from Satiation
Jeff Galak, Joseph P. Redden an Justin Kruger
The stakes might be higher than you think. “Satiation is a real problem,” says Jeff Galak, a marketing professor at Carnegie Mellon University and the lead author of the study published recently online in the Journal of Consumer Research. “If we stop enjoying the things we enjoy, we’ll be forced to find the next best thing. And if that continues in perpetuity, we’ll never be happy with what we have.”

Featured in Wall Street Journal Online
"When Times Are Tough, Why Do We Avoid Asking For Help?" June 17, 2009
Escaping the Gift Economy
Jean‐Sébastien Marcoux
But as we struggle with financial challenges, job losses and more, we are often less likely to seek help from our social networks, instead paying someone to do the job – at least that’s according to a forthcoming article in the Journal of Consumer Research.

Featured in MSNBC
"Stuck in a rut? Call on memory for a good time" June 16, 2009
Variety Amnesia: Recalling Past Variety Can Accelerate Recovery from Satiation
Jeff Galak, Joseph P. Redden an Justin Kruger
Galak and colleagues have put some science to this, primarily among college students: "We demonstrate that simply thinking about the variety of similar experiences one has had since last being exposed to the now-disliked stimulus accelerates recovery from satiation," Galak and his colleagues write in the Journal of Consumer Research in an article published online last month and slated for the print edition in December.

October 2008

Volume 35, Number 3
© 2008 by JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH, Inc. • Vol. 35 • October 2008
All rights reserved. 0093-5301/2008/3503-0012$10.00
DOI: 10.1086/589564

Flying under the Radar: Perverse Package Size Effects on Consumption Self‐Regulation

Rita Coelho do Vale

Rik Pieters

Marcel Zeelenberg*

Consumers believe that small package formats of hedonic, but not of utilitarian, products help to regulate consumption—especially when their self‐regulatory concerns are activated. These beliefs may backfire and increase consumption of hedonic products. Specifically, activating self‐regulatory concerns had no consumption effects when tempting products came in small package formats. Yet, when tempting products came in large package formats, consumers deliberated most before consumption, were least likely to consume, and consumed the least. This illustrates how small temptations can remain undetected (“flying under the radar”) and large package formats may reduce consumption as a result of the experienced self‐control conflict.

Electronically published June 19, 2008

John Deighton served as editor and Susan Broniarczyk served as associate editor for this article.

  • Rita Coelho do Vale is an assistant professor of marketing () at Instituto Superior de Economica e Gestao (ISEG Economics and Business School), Technical University of Lisbon, Rua Miguel Lupi, 20, 1200‐078 Lisbon, Portugal. Rik Pieters is professor of marketing (), and Marcel Zeelenberg is professor of psychology (), both at Tilburg University, P.O. Box 90153, 5000 LE Tilburg, Netherlands. Correspondence: Rik Pieters. The research on which this article is based is part of the first author’s dissertation, defended at Tilburg University. It was supported by a grant from the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology. We thank an anonymous reviewer for suggesting the “flying under the radar” metaphor.

Close Popup