All Journals > The American Naturalist > April 2006 > Challenges in the Analysis of Static Allometries

Article Tools

Search for Related Articles

Highlighted Article

"Density-dependent male mating harassment, female resistance and male mimicry"
Thomas P. Gosden and Erik I. Svensson


male blue-tailed damselfly matting with his doppelganger

A male mating with his female doppelganger (photo: Erik Svensson) 

Females in the blue-tailed damselfly (Ischnura elegans) occur in three different inherited color forms: green, red, and blue, with the blue form looking confusingly similar to males, perhaps to avoid repeated excessive sexual harassment. By dusting the males with a fluorescent powder, the authors monitored both the intensity of male mating harassment and the number of matings of the three female forms. The avoidance through male mimicry only seems to benefit the females when their “more attractive” sisters are at higher densities.

Press Release

Snapshot of Speciation
Study catches two bird populations as they split into seperate species

A new study finds that a change in a single gene has sent two closely related bird populations on their way to becoming two distinct species. The study, published in the August issue of The American Naturalist, is one of only a few to investigate the specific genetic changes that drive two populations toward speciation.

Parasites May Help Keep Sex On Top

What’s so great about sex? From an evolutionary perspective, the answer is not as obvious as one might think. An article published in the July issue of The American Naturalist suggests that sex may have evolved in part as a defense against parasites.

Michael J. Wade to Receive 2009 Sewall Wright Award

Harvard Biologist Jonathan Losos to Receive 2009 E. O. Wilson Naturalist Award

In the News

Featured in Scientific American
"Are Parasites To Thank for Sex?" July 8, 2009
The Maintenance of Sex, Clonal Dynamics, and Host-Parasite Coevolution in a Mixed Population of Sexual and Asexual Snails
Jukka Jokela, Mark F. Dybdahl, and Curtis M. Lively
A study in the journal The American Naturalist implies that parasites helped drive the development of sex, because the shuffling of genes gives sex-produced progeny an advantage over asexual genetic clones. Cynthia Graber reports.

Featured in ScienceNOW
"On the Road to a New Species" June 15, 2009
Difference in Plumage Color Used in Species Recognition between Incipient Species Is Linked to a Single Amino Acid Substitution in the Melanocortin‐1 Receptor
J. Albert C. Uy, Robert G. Moyle, Christopher E. Filardi, and Zachary A. Cheviron, Associate Editor: Ben C. Sheldon, Editor: Monica A. Geber
Next, the researchers evaluated whether this color change might make any difference to the birds. They put stuffed birds of either color into the territories of live flycatchers. Flycatchers are not bothered by most foreign birds, but they will attack potential rivals of the same species. Black bird decoys drew angry responses from black birds but little reaction from brown-belly birds and vice versa, Uy and his colleagues report in the August issue of The American Naturalist.

April 2006

Volume 167, Number 4
Am Nat 2006. Vol. 167, pp. 606–611
0003-0147/2006/16704-40949$15.00
DOI: 10.1086/501075

A Matter of Measurements: Challenges and Approaches in the Comparative Analysis of Static Allometries

Armin P. Moczek*

Department of Biology and Indiana Molecular Biology Institute, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana 47405

Abstract:

Comparisons of static allometries are frequently used to gain insights into patterns and processes underlying morphological and developmental evolution. A study by J. L. Tomkins and coworkers, recently published in the American Naturalist, examined complex nonlinear allometries in three insect species in which males are dimorphic in the expression of secondary sexual traits. Employing a novel approach to analyzing male allometries in these organisms, the authors were able to show that developmental reprogramming of trait primordia is not necessary to explain allometric scaling in two of the species examined, contrary to several previous studies on the same species. Instead, male dimorphisms could be explained by simple exponential growth, an important result that carries with it major evolutionary and developmental implications. Using this study as an example, I highlight some of the methodological challenges involved in analyzing and comparing static allometries and in inferring the developmental processes that underlie them. I end by discussing how correct application of hypothesis testing, on one side, and basic anatomy and developmental biology, on the other, should guide how morphology is measured.

Submitted March 18, 2005; Accepted September 7, 2005; Electronically published March 13, 2006

Keywords:

alternative phenotypes, Onthophagus, plasticity, polyphenism, static allometry, reprogramming.

Associate Editor: Troy Day

Editor: Jonathan B. Losos

Cited by

ROBERT J. KNELL. (2009) On the analysis of non-linear allometries. Ecological Entomology 34:1, 1-11
Online publication date: 1-Mar-2009.
CrossRef
Armin P. Moczek, Joseph L. Tomkins. (2009) PATTERNS OF THRESHOLD EVOLUTION IN POLYPHENIC INSECTS UNDER DIFFERENT DEVELOPMENTAL MODELS. Evolution 63:2, 459
CrossRef
Harald F. Parzer, Armin P. Moczek. (2008) RAPID ANTAGONISTIC COEVOLUTION BETWEEN PRIMARY AND SECONDARY SEXUAL CHARACTERS IN HORNED BEETLES. Evolution 62:9, 2423-2428
Online publication date: 1-Oct-2008.
CrossRef
Russell Bonduriansky. (2007) SEXUAL SELECTION AND ALLOMETRY: A CRITICAL REAPPRAISAL OF THE EVIDENCE AND IDEAS. Evolution 61:4, 838-849
Online publication date: 1-May-2007.
CrossRef
Joseph L. Tomkins, Janne S. Kotiaho, and Natasha R. LeBas. (2006) Major Differences in Minor Allometries: A Reply to Moczek.. The American Naturalist 167:4, 612-618
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2006.
Close Popup