Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, Biological Laboratories, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138
abstract:
Accurately quantifying and interpreting the processes and outcomes of competition among plants is essential for evaluating theories of plant community organization and evolution. We argue that many current experimental approaches to quantifying competitive interactions introduce size bias, which may significantly impact the quantitative and qualitative conclusions drawn from studies. Size bias generally arises when estimates of competitive ability are erroneously influenced by the initial size of competing individuals. We employ a series of quantitative thought experiments to demonstrate the potential for size bias in analysis of four traditional experimental designs (pairwise, replacement series, additive series, and response surfaces) either when only final measurements are available or when both initial and final measurements are collected. We distinguish three questions relevant to describing competitive interactions: Which species dominates? Which species gains? and How do species affect each other? The choice of experimental design and measurements greatly influences the scope of inference permitted. Conditions under which the latter two questions can give biased information are tabulated. We outline a new approach to characterizing competition that avoids size bias and that improves the concordance between research question and experimental design. The implications of the choice of size metrics used to quantify both the initial state and the responses of elements in interspecific mixtures are discussed. The relevance of size bias in competition studies with organisms other than plants is also discussed.
competition, thought experiments, design of competition experiments, size bias, replacement series, additive series.
Cited by
Christopher J. Lortie, Roy Turkington. (2008) Species-specific positive effects in an annual plant community.
Oikos 117:10, 1511-1521
Online publication date: 1-Nov-2008.
CrossRef Bernice C. Hwang, William K. Lauenroth. (2008) Effect of nitrogen, water and neighbor density on the growth of Hesperis matronalis and two native perennials.
Biological Invasions 10:5, 771-779
Online publication date: 1-Jul-2008.
CrossRef W. Stanley Harpole, Katharine N. Suding. (2008) Frequency-dependence stabilizes competitive interactions among four annual plants.
Ecology Letters 10:12, 1164-1169
Online publication date: 1-Jan-2008.
CrossRef ROB W. BROOKER, FERNANDO T. MAESTRE, RAGAN M. CALLAWAY, CHRISTOPHER L. LORTIE, LOHENGRIN A. CAVIERES, GEORGES KUNSTLER, PIERRE LIANCOURT, KATJA TIELBÖRGER, JUSTIN M. J. TRAVIS, FABIEN ANTHELME, CRISTINA ARMAS, LLUIS COLL, EMMANUEL CORCKET, SYLVAIN DELZON, ESTELLE FOREY, ZAAL KIKVIDZE, JOHAN OLOFSSON, FRANCISCO PUGNAIRE, CONSTANZA L. QUIROZ, PATRICK SACCONE, KATJA SCHIFFERS, MERAV SEIFAN, BLAIZE TOUZARD, RICHARD MICHALET. (2007) Facilitation in plant communities: the past, the present, and the future.
Journal of Ecology 0:0, 070908024102002-???
Online publication date: 6-Oct-2007.
CrossRef Carsten F. Dormann. (2007) Competition hierarchy, transitivity and additivity: investigating the effect of fertilisation on plant–plant interactions using three common bryophytes.
Plant Ecology 191:2, 171-184
Online publication date: 28-Jul-2007.
CrossRef METTE KLINDT ANDERSEN, HENRIK HAUGGAARD-NIELSEN, JACOB WEINER, ERIK STEEN JENSEN. (2007) Competitive dynamics in two- and three-component intercrops.
Journal of Applied Ecology 44:3, 545-551
Online publication date: 1-Jul-2007.
CrossRef L. KIRWAN, A. LÜSCHER, M. T. SEBASTIÀ, J. A. FINN, R. P. COLLINS, C. PORQUEDDU, A. HELGADOTTIR, O. H. BAADSHAUG, C. BROPHY, C. CORAN, S. DALMANNSDÓTTIR, I. DELGADO, A. ELGERSMA, M. FOTHERGILL, B. E. FRANKOW-LINDBERG, P. GOLINSKI, P. GRIEU, A. M. GUSTAVSSON, M. HÖGLIND, O. HUGUENIN-ELIE, C. ILIADIS, M. JØRGENSEN, Z. KADZIULIENE, T. KARYOTIS, T. LUNNAN, M. MALENGIER, S. MALTONI, V. MEYER, D. NYFELER, P. NYKANEN-KURKI, J. PARENTE, H. J. SMIT, U. THUMM, J. CONNOLLY. (2007) Evenness drives consistent diversity effects in intensive grassland systems across 28 European sites.
Journal of Ecology 95:3, 530-539
Online publication date: 1-Jun-2007.
CrossRef Matthias Suter, Dieter Ramseier, Sabine Guesewell, John Connolly. (2007) Convergence patterns and multiple species interactions in a designed plant mixture of five species.
Oecologia 151:3, 499-511
Online publication date: 2-Apr-2007.
CrossRef MARK V. WILSON. (2007) Measuring the components of competition along productivity gradients.
Journal of Ecology 95:2, 301-308
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2007.
CrossRef Catherine Picon-Cochard, Lluis Coll, Philippe Balandier. (2006) The role of below-ground competition during early stages of secondary succession: the case of 3-year-old Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) seedlings in an abandoned grassland.
Oecologia 148:3, 373-383
Online publication date: 22-Jun-2006.
CrossRef Walter Zegada-Lizarazu, Luke Kanyomeka, Yasuhiro Izumi, Morio Iijima. (2006) Pearl Millet Developed Deep Roots and Changed Water Sources by Competition with Intercropped Cowpea in the Semiarid Environment of Northern Namibia.
Plant Production Science 9:4, 355-363
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2006.
CrossRef Walter Zegada-Lizarazu, Yasuhiro Izumi, Morio Iijima. (2006) Water Competition of Intercropped Pearl Millet with Cowpea under Drought and Soil Compaction Stresses.
Plant Production Science 9:2, 123-132
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2006.
CrossRef R. Matyssek, R. Agerer, D. Ernst, J.-C. Munch, W. Oßwald, H. Pretzsch, E. Priesack, H. Schnyder, D. Treutter. (2005) The Plant's Capacity in Regulating Resource Demand.
Plant Biology 7:6, 560-580
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2005.
CrossRef I. M. Reiter, K. -H. Häberle, A. J. Nunn, C. Heerdt, H. Reitmayer, R. Grote, R. Matyssek. (2005) Competitive strategies in adult beech and spruce: space-related foliar carbon investment versus carbon gain.
Oecologia 146:3, 337-349
Online publication date: 26-Nov-2005.
CrossRef P. Sobkowicz, E. Tendziagolska. (2005) Competition and Productivity in Mixture of Oats and Wheat.
Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science 191:5, 377-385
Online publication date: 1-Nov-2005.
CrossRef JAMES F. CAHILL, STEVEN W. KEMBEL, DANNY J. GUSTAFSON. (2005) Differential genetic influences on competitive effect and response in Arabidopsis thaliana.
Journal of Ecology 93:5, 958-967
Online publication date: 1-Nov-2005.
CrossRef Alessandra R. Kozovits, Rainer Matyssek, J. Barbro Winkler, Axel Gottlein, Helmut Blaschke, Thorsten E. E. Grams. (2005) Above-ground space sequestration determines competitive success in juvenile beech and spruce trees.
New Phytologist 167:1, 181-196
Online publication date: 1-Aug-2005.
CrossRef DIETER RAMSEIER, JOHN CONNOLLY, FAKHRI A. BAZZAZ. (2005) Carbon dioxide regime, species identity and influence of species initial abundance as determinants of change in stand biomass composition in five-species communities: an investigation using a simplex design and RGRD analysis.
Journal of Ecology 93:3, 502-511
Online publication date: 1-Jul-2005.
CrossRef Olusegun O. Osunkoya, Farah E. Othman, Rafhiah S. Kahar. (2005) Growth and competition between seedlings of an invasive plantation tree, Acacia mangium, and those of a native Borneo heath-forest species, Melastoma beccarianum.
Ecological Research 20:2, 205-214
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2005.
CrossRef John Connolly, Peter Wayne. (2005) Assessing determinants of community biomass composition in two-species plant competition studies.
Oecologia 142:3, 450-457
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2005.
CrossRef Nancy H. Furness, Peter A. Jolliffe, Mahesh K. Upadhyaya. (2005) Ultraviolet-B Radiation and Plant Competition: Experimental Approaches and Underlying Mechanisms.
Photochemistry and Photobiology 81:5, 1026
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2005.
CrossRef D. J. GUSTAFSON, D. J. GIBSON, D. L. NICKRENT. (2004) Competitive relationships of Andropogon gerardii (Big Bluestem) from remnant and restored native populations and select cultivated varieties.
Functional Ecology 18:3, 451-457
Online publication date: 1-Jul-2004.
CrossRef Paul S. Giller, Helmut Hillebrand, Ulrike-G. Berninger, Mark O. Gessner, Stephen Hawkins, Pablo Inchausti, Cheryl Inglis, Heather Leslie, Björn Malmqvist, Michael T. Monaghan, Peter J. Morin, Gregory O'Mullan. (2004) Biodiversity effects on ecosystem functioning: emerging issues and their experimental test in aquatic environments.
Oikos 104:3, 423-436
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2004.
CrossRef Bradley J. Cardinale, Anthony R. Ives, Pablo Inchausti. (2004) Effects of species diversity on the primary productivity of ecosystems: extending our spatial and temporal scales of inference.
Oikos 104:3, 437-450
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2004.
CrossRef Alexandra Weigelt, Peter Jolliffe. (2003) Indices of plant competition.
Journal of Ecology 91:5, 707-720
Online publication date: 1-Nov-2003.
CrossRef E. Charles Morris. (2003) How does fertility of the substrate affect intraspecific competition? Evidence and synthesis from self-thinning.
Ecological Research 18:3, 287-305
Online publication date: 1-Jun-2003.
CrossRef Pieter Poot, Hans Lambers. (2003) Are trade-offs in allocation pattern and root morphology related to species abundance? A congeneric comparison between rare and common species in the south-western Australian flora.
Journal of Ecology 91:1, 58-67
Online publication date: 1-Mar-2003.
CrossRef E. P. McDonald, E. L. Kruger, D. E. Riemenschneider, J. G. Isebrands. (2003) Competitive status influences tree-growth responses to elevated CO2 and O3 in aggrading aspen stands.
Functional Ecology 16:6, 792-801
Online publication date: 1-Jan-2003.
CrossRef Christopher J. Lortie, Roy Turkington. (2002) The effect of initial seed density on the structure of a desert annual plant community.
Journal of Ecology 90:3, 435-445
Online publication date: 1-Jul-2002.
CrossRef T. E. E. Grams, A. R. Kozovits, I. M. Reiter, J. Barbro Winkler, M. Sommerkorn, H. Blaschke, K.-H. Häberle, R. Matyssek. (2002) Quantifying Competitiveness in Woody Plants.
Plant Biology 4:2, 153-158
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2002.
CrossRef James F. Cahill. (2002) What evidence is necessary in studies which separate root and shoot competition along productivity gradients?.
Journal of Ecology 90:1, 201-205
Online publication date: 1-Mar-2002.
CrossRef